Front Row Reviewers

Jul 17, 2025 | Reviews

Cottonwood Heights Arts Council Gives an Electrifying Performance of “The Lightning Thief: The Percy Jackson Musical”

Front Row Reviewers

Front Row Reviewers

Review By M. Bennet, Front Row Reviewers 

Cottonwood Heights Arts Council brings The Lightning Thief: The Percy Jackson Musical an electric, youthful production that crackles with myth, humor, and heart. Adapted from Rick Riordan’s beloved novel by Joe Tracz and Rob Rokicki, The Lightning Thief: The Percy Jackson Musical is a punchy high-energy take on the world of Greek Mythology. Misunderstood teenager Percy Jackson learns that he is a demi-god and is sent to Camp Half-Blood, a haven for others like him. Though all the residents at camp have a god or goddess parent, Percy has extra special parentage and his father sends him on a quest to find the stolen thunderbolt of Zeus. The story smartly parallels real-world adolescent struggles: feeling like an outsider, misplaced and underestimated. What this cast accomplishes is no small feat—they bring a thunderbolt of emotional clarity to a whirlwind adventure. 

Garrett Stephenson as Percy Jackson is the eye of this stormy tale. From his opening in “The Day I Got Expelled,” it’s clear Stephenson is ready to lead. He brings to the stage a refreshingly grounded, sarcastic, and emotionally nuanced portrayal of Percy—half god, half mortal, and all heart. Stephenson’s “Good Kid” is a clear standout, filled with frustration, hope, and the aching search for identity.  

Ellie England as Annabeth Chase is the sharp-witted daughter of Athena we need. England captures the pain and ambition of a girl raised in the shadows of the gods of never living up to a parent’s expectations. She delivers the role with energy, confidence, and a brilliant voice. Logan Stacey as Grover Underwood, the loyal satyr best friend, is instantly likable. Stacey should also be commended for moving around so well in his half-goat pants. My five-year-old son, who attended The Lightning Thief: The Percy Jackson Musical with me and loves the story, was astounded every time he saw them. Stacey brings humor and earnestness to the role, especially in “The Tree on the Hill.” His timing, physicality, and emotional honesty help solidify the trio’s chemistry.  

Jaden Burnett as Luke Castellan is quietly powerful. Burnett’s performance as the brooding, betrayed son of Hermes layers charisma over resentment. When his motives are revealed, his portrayal of Luke’s transformation is subtle and impactful. His delivery in “The Last Day of Summer” is menacing, a strong contrast to the lighter moments in the show. 

Kat Tietjen tackles multiple roles such as Percy’s mother, the Oracle, Charon, and even the leader of a group of squirrels. Tietjen does so with distinct voices and emotional clarity. As Sally Jackson, she brings warmth and maternal strength. As the oracle, she is chilling and ethereal. Tietjen is a true utility player, switching gears with grace. Doug Hendrickson brings steady wisdom and quiet authority to Chiron. Hendrickson’s interpretation leans gentle rather than stoic. There is also a feeling of whimsy about him when one sees him prancing about with horse legs 

Daniel “Pitt” Pittam plays Dionysis, who is punished with being Camp Half-Blood’s leader. His “Mr. D” is grumpy and hilarious. Other gods are the surfer dude Poseidon played by Sam Fisher, and violent Ares played by Austinn Le. Le also plays several other roles and seems to be having the time of his life as the harpy substitute teacher Mrs. Dodds.  

This show has a large ensemble who brings passion and precision to every group number. The choreography (Karllen Johnson) is creative and dynamic. From the campfire at Camp Half-Blood to the trip through the Underworld, the cast creates whole worlds through movement and imagination. 

The creative team deserves high praise. Director Lauri Baird clearly trusts her cast and understands the emotional thread of this mythological story. Music Director Robert Bedont navigated the challenges of Rokicki’s high-energy score with a balanced and resonant sound. The live band is a treat. It is a rarity in community productions, and they do amazingly well. Set and Graphic Designer Facio Long has created a magical place for these magical mythical characters to romp and roam. 

Set and Graphic Designer Facio Long has created a magical mythical place for this large and talented cast can move. The colors and set pieces add to the mysterious and fantastical elements of Percy Jackson.

My son loved it so much that he kept his ticket so he could “come and see the show again, with the same people!” He was somewhat disappointed when I told him how tickets work. This show is not just for fans of the book series. While Riordan readers will thrill at faithful moments, anyone who’s ever felt like an outsider, battled self-doubt, or struggled to feel understood by their parents will find meaning here. This isn’t just a musical, it is a coming-of-age story wrapped in prophecy and power chords. I recommend it wholeheartedly.  

Cottonwood Heights Arts Council presents The Lightning Thief: The Percy Jackson Musical, Book by Joe Tracz, Music and Lyrics by Rob Rokicki, Adapted from the book The Lightning Thief by Rick Riordan. 
Butler Middle School Auditorium, 7530 S 2700 E, Cottonwood Heights, UT
July 11, 13, 15, 17, 19 7:30 PM
Tickets: $12 General Admission / $10 Seniors & Children
Website
Facebook
General seating. Arrive early for the best view. Light concessions and restrooms are located in the main lobby.

Front Row Reviewers

Front Row Reviewers

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

AlphaOmega Captcha Classica  –  Enter Security Code